saudi imperialism, secret cospiracy, Salafis, evidence betrayal, Turkey, NATO, religious freedom in the Islamic world

ISLAM
Killing apostates not in Qu'ran but a strongly held view in the masses
by Bernardo Cervellera
Fundamentalist theologians have led people to believe that apostasy undermines the unity of the Ummah, the Muslim community. But for Prof Francesco Zannini, who teaches at the Pontifical Institute of Arabic and Islamic Studies, the issue is hotly debated amongst Muslims.


Rome (AsiaNews) – The recent case of Abdul Rahman, a Christian convert from Islam threatened with the death penalty, has re-opened the debate over the practice of enforcing capital punishment for apostasy in Muslim countries. For Francesco Zannini, professor of Modern Islam at the Pontifical Institute of  Arabic and Islamic Studies (PISAI), the death penalty is not prescribed in the Qu'ran even though people believe it is. What is clear though is that fundamentalists are fanning the flames on this issue and that Muslim governments acquiesce.
Is the death penalty for apostasy applied in all Islamic cultures?
Support for killing a convert to another religion is strong at a popular level in some countries that enforce the Sharia like Saudi Arabia, Iran, and states within Malaysia. But elsewhere in the Islamic world, there is a debate over whether it is right to kill an apostate or not.
It must be first said is that the Qu'ran does not provide any precise guidelines in the matter. Indeed, it says: "There is no compulsion in religion. Verily, the Right Path has become distinct from the wrong path" (Sura, 2: 256). Even though other verses in the Qu'ran can be interpreted as justification for killing since they speak of making war against the enemies of Islam, most suggest that anyone who rejects Islam after accepting it will be punished at the end of his life in the Last Judgement.
The hadith (the collected sayings of the prophet) that deal with the issue carry little weight. Some fundamentalists like [sheikh Yusuf] al-Qaradawi, who speaks on al-Jazeera, claim that killing an apostate is right so long as there is a single hadith that orders it. Others say instead that we cannot rely on the hadith to impose the death penalty.
The debate over apostasy has become more complex. Muslims are still discussing how to define it, whether renouncing Islam has to be done in words, in deeds or just in the heart.
Some intellectuals like Egyptian Nasr Abu Zaid and Bangladeshi Taslima Nazrin have been declared apostate in ways that seem to reflect a desire to get rid of people who dissent from the dominant way of thinking.
Whatever the case, the legal and theological bases of apostasy are rather weak, and the debate surrounding it is heated. On the one hand, we have people like Muhammad al-Ghazali, a modern fundamentalist who defends the death penalty for apostates. On the other, there are Egyptian human rights groups who are critical of the practice. Many Lebanese, Syrian and Egyptian Muslims also believe that no one can use the Qu'ran to draw the inference that killing apostates is necessary.
Does the death penalty go back to the origins of Islam or has it emerged in recent decades with the rise of fundamentalism?
In the beginning apostasy got mixed up with politics, namely with what to do with non Muslims who might be spies for the enemy. This ruthless attitude got worse under Abu Bakr, the first caliph. His successor however, Omar, did not even apply the rule on Islam's enemies. Afterwards there was an attempt to codify the practice but it was never easily accepted in Islam.
Why is support for killing apostates so widespread at a popular level?
Because there is a strong consensus among Muslims that one cannot abandon one's faith (and this is stressed in the Qu'ran). This led to the persecution of heretics and apostates. Al-Hallaj, one of the great Muslim mystics died a martyr's death at the hands of his fellow Muslims. In this sense, the political use of apostasy by rulers was important in manipulating popular attitudes.
What drives Muslims to want to kill anyone guilty of apostasy in the name of their religion, relatives included?
There are two factors that come into play; one that is spiritual and the other that is linked to their sense of community. Since Islam is seen as a totality, leaving it is seen as damaging its growth. It is not a matter of faith, but one of the Ummah or community. An apostate, a Muslim who converts, is seen as someone who is undermining the social cohesion of the family itself. For example, in Malaysia, people are talking about what to do with modernised Muslims, i.e. those who "do not act like true Muslims" as defined by the tradition. Some Qu'ranic scholars insist that they should be sentenced to death. By contrast, in Indonesia, where the principles of Pancasila recognise freedom for five religions, families can have members who are Muslim, Christian, Hindu, etc.
It is also important to make a distinction between the Sharia, which is divinely ordained, and Fiqh, i.e. Islamic jurisprudence, which is based on human intellect. Hence, some Muslims ask why, since there is no divine ruling [about apostasy], man should assume the right to pass laws?
How strong are liberal voices who defend religious freedom in the Islamic world?
Tolerance is present in the constitutions of Muslim countries except for Saudi Arabia, Iran and Sudan. The Saudis have gone so far as to refuse to sign the Charter on Human Rights because they do not accept religious freedom.
Other Muslim countries recognise religious freedom but do not protect it, partly because they have mixed constitutions. Some sections are inspired by the Sharia; others refer to international treaties. And in all, Islam is seen as the basis and inspiration for law-making. This opens the door to manipulation.
Among the masses, fundamentalism, which must protect itself from the attacks of the West, has been growing. Fundamentalist theologians manipulate the Qu'ran. They refer to Muhammad's struggle against Pagans (during his stay in Makkah) and view the fight against apostasy as part of the fight against Paganism and idolatry. This is why killing a Westerner, a Christian, or even a moderate Muslim is seen as justified.
Aren't Muslim governments a bit too shy in asserting the independence of their constitutions vis-à-vis Islam?
Of course they are. Muslim governments are afraid of the masses and of fundamentalists. Their constitutions assert that sovereignty is vested in the people, but then say that Islam is above everything. This misunderstanding leaves people secure in their traditional view of things, which fundamentalists like to heat up as part of their dream to see the entire world under Islam.
What can we do? The Pope and many governments have demanded clemency for Abdul Rahman…
The West faces a problem. There is not accountability for the funds invested in education and culture. More often than not, the money goes to governments who use it to strengthen their power bases and not to moderate voices.
None the less, whatever is done, it must avoid the use of force. Muslims by and large believe that Islam is in danger. If changes are pursued through force this fear can turn into closure.
Our appeals must be based on humanitarian grounds and connected to the fate of Muslim intellectuals to show that Islam itself defends religious freedom.

YouTube

YouTube Spotlight 

  • Nessuno Unius REI
    Nessuno Unius REI ha pubblicato un commento 
    1 secondo fa
    saudi imperialism [secret cospiracy of Salafis, evidence betrayal of Turkey, NATO stab in the back] Prosecutor yanked from Turkish Christian murder trials. Asserting a link to earlier killing, he is removed from High Council duty. Istanbul, December 7 (World Watch Monitor) — A High Council prosecutor probing links between the Malatya murders of three Christians in eastern Turkey and the earlier assassination of a Christian newspaper editor was abruptly transferred from his position last week and re-assigned prosecution duties in an Istanbul court. Prosecutor Hikmet Usta was preparing objections to the verdict of the Turkish Supreme Court that "no illegal group" had been behind the January 2007 murder of Turkish Armenian journalist Hrant Dink. "There was an illegal group, and there is evidence," Usta protested to the Turkish media.
  • Nessuno Unius REI
    Nessuno Unius REI ha pubblicato un commento 
    8 secondi fa
    saudi imperialism [secret cospiracy of Salafis, evidence betrayal of Turkey, NATO stab in the back] As a member of the High Council of Judges and Prosecutors, Usta was investigating in his appeals process the connections between Dink's murder and the Malatya massacre, in which two Turkish Christians and a German citizen were tortured and stabbed to death in the Zirve Christian publishing house office on April 18, 2007. "This cannot be called a 'routine' procedure, to remove a prosecutor wanting to intensify his appeals investigation," Zirve plaintiff lawyer Erdal Dogan told Taraf newspaper Dec. 2 Dogan noted that in the very same way, previous prosecutors trying to uncover the real perpetrators behind the Dink and Zirve murders, as well as the killing of Italian Catholic priest Andrea Santoro in 2006, had also been transferred suddenly from their duties to another court.
  • Nessuno Unius REI
    Nessuno Unius REI ha pubblicato un commento 
    44 secondi fa
    saudi imperialism [secret cospiracy of Salafis, evidence betrayal of Turkey, NATO stab in the back] In September, the Turkish Justice Ministry removed two prosecutors and two judges who had been trying the Malatya case just two days before a week of hearings on the case was to begin. The sudden changes left only the presiding judge familiar with the massive files of evidence on the murders. Top perpetrator suspect testifies. Last month, another week-long series of hearings in Malatya focused on the latest indictment, which accuses 19 perpetrators of inciting the five young suspects caught at the scene of the Malatya killings. On the first day of the November 12-16 hearings, prime suspect Ret. Gen. Hursit Toron was called to the witness stand.
  • Drakorthic
    Drakorthic ha pubblicato un commento 
    48 secondi fa
    Unius REI Why are you ignoring me Mommy?
  • Nessuno Unius REI
    Nessuno Unius REI ha pubblicato un commento 
    56 secondi fa
    saudi imperialism [secret cospiracy of Salafis, evidence betrayal of Turkey, NATO stab in the back] A retired four-star general, Toron was brought from the Silivri prison near Istanbul on Nov. 12 to testify in Malatya. Toron also is accused in a separate case of involvement in an alleged conspiracy by military officials to unseat Turkey's ruling Justice and Peace Party government, for acts of terrorism against Turkey's non-Muslim minorities. Toron emphatically denied "the tiniest information, interest or involvement" either before or after the Malatya murders, declaring that he had never had any contact with any of the five suspects. He also discredited witness testimony by Ilker Cinar, another suspected perpetrator.
  • facebook5878
    facebook5878 ha pubblicato un commento 
    1 minuto fa
    lord vándor
  • Nessuno Unius REI
    Nessuno Unius REI ha pubblicato un commento 
    1 minuto fa
    saudi imperialism [secret cospiracy of Salafis, evidence betrayal of Turkey, NATO stab in the back] A former member of the gendarmerie — a law-enforcement arm of the military — Cinar claimed that he was working with a clandestine operation set up within the Turkish military to target Turkey's Muslim converts to Christianity. He said he was commissioned to infiltrate Turkey's Protestant communities by pretending to become a Christian and then later publicly "reconvert to Islam," to expose Christians as a threat to national security. Toron countered that Cinar's testimony was slander based on "fabricated documents," designed to blacken the reputation of the Turkish military. He stated that Cinar's career in the military had been marked by drunkenness and "undisciplined behaviour," including a five months' prison sentence.
  • Nessuno Unius REI
    Nessuno Unius REI ha pubblicato un commento 
    1 minuto fa
    saudi imperialism [secret cospiracy of Salafis, evidence betrayal of Turkey, NATO stab in the back] Although Toron had initially denied visiting Malatya, the indictment documents indicate that he visited the city twice before the murders, once just the day before the killings. In addition to Toron and Cinar, former Malatya gendarmerie regiment commander Col. Mehmet Ulger and Maj. Haydar Yesil testified to the court and were cross-examined during the November hearings. The defendants reiterated that the prosecutors preparing the indictment against them had in fact accepted disinformation without any real evidence being produced. While confirming that the Malatya gendarmerie had collected information regarding the Zirve staff and other activities of local Protestant Christians,
  • Nessuno Unius REI
    Nessuno Unius REI ha pubblicato un commento 
    1 minuto fa
    saudi imperialism [secret cospiracy of Salafis, evidence betrayal of Turkey, NATO stab in the back] the military officers insisted this was not illegal, and had been undertaken with legal oversight by the Turkish state. The Malatya trial is slated to resume with the 52nd hearing on Jan. 14, 2013, for another week of consecutive hearings to record testimony from the accused perpetrators still scheduled to testify.
  • Drakorthic
    Drakorthic ha pubblicato un commento 
    5 minuti fa
    Unius REI Are you my Mommy?
  • Nessuno Unius REI
    Nessuno Unius REI ha pubblicato un commento 
    14 minuti fa
    saudi Arabia imperialism for satanAllah [Islamists extreme threat of death for all mankind] Likely to lose constitution vote, Egyptian Christians gird for long struggle. Protesters outside the Egyptian presidential palace on Dec. 7 (Photo: Mohamed El Dahshan / Creative Commons) Religious freedom will have to be won within Islamic system of laws Cairo, December 14 (World Watch Monitor) — Politically connected Christians in Egypt give credit to the Muslim Brotherhood for one thing: they can win elections. The Brotherhood got 13 million ordinary Egyptians, many of them poor, rural and illiterate, to the polls in June to vote for their presidential candidate, Mohamed Morsi.
  • Nessuno Unius REI
    Nessuno Unius REI ha pubblicato un commento 
    14 minuti fa
    saudi Arabia imperialism for satanAllah [Islamists extreme threat of death for all mankind] Governing has been a different matter. "What is helping us today is that the Muslim Brotherhood and political Islam are not always clever," said Hassan Ismail, secretary general of the Egyptian Union of Human Rights Organizations. He has been networking among Christians, moderate Muslims and secularists to assemble a political counterweight to the more numerous supporters of the Brotherhood and the fundamentalist Salafis. "Average people are starting to be against them because they don't see anything helping them," Ismail said, passing a sultry autumn afternoon at a Cairo café table. "Our bet is on the stupidity of the Muslim Brotherhood."
  • Nessuno Unius REI
    Nessuno Unius REI ha pubblicato un commento 
    15 minuti fa
    saudi arabia imperialism for satanAllah [Islamists extreme threat of death for all mankind] Since the January 2011 revolution that toppled former President Hosni Mubarak, economic growth has slowed and Egypt's unemployment rate has been running at 12 percent. Prices are up by 20 percent, and likely would be higher if not for the central bank's raid on its foreign cash reserves to prop up the value of the Egyptian pound. Textile workers and doctors alike have staged walkouts for higher wages. Tourism is moribund. The day after he was enthroned, new Coptic Pope Tawadros II said he and Egypt's 10 million Christians would reject the proposed constitution, drafted by a committee dominated by Islamists, if it retained language establishing a religious state.
  • Nessuno Unius REI
    Nessuno Unius REI ha pubblicato un commento 
    15 minuti fa
    saudi arabia imperialism for satanAllah [Islamists extreme threat of death for all mankind] "The Muslim Brotherhood, they don't know politics. Every day they provide us with proof," said Dr. Ehab El Kharrat , a psychiatrist, member of Egypt's upper house of Parliament, and a Christian member of the country's constitution-drafting committee until he walked out in protest. "They are not the underdog any more. Now they are making one mistake after another." This was the view several weeks ago, when growing public exasperation with the impotence of the Morsi government appeared to open a plausible path for Christians to secure some space for themselves alongside Egypt's widely popular Islamist political movements.
  • Nessuno Unius REI
    Nessuno Unius REI ha pubblicato un commento 
    15 minuti fa
    [Islamists extreme threat of death for all mankind] But it also was before Morsi made his late-November lurch for power with a series of decrees -- since rescinded -- that expanded his authority and shielded him from court oversight. It was before he ordered the committee drafting the constitution, already deserted by frustrated Christians and the object of widespread protests, to finish the job in a single night, and scheduled a popular vote for Dec. 15. Cairo streets filled with tens of thousands of protesters, and with even more Morsi supporters, in sometimes violent confrontations. Tanks lined up in front of the presidential palace. In the streets, the dividing line has become a largely religious one: The Brotherhood and Salafis on one side chanting in support of Islam and majority rule;
  • Nessuno Unius REI
    Nessuno Unius REI ha pubblicato un commento 
    16 minuti fa
    saudi Arabia imperialism for satanAllah [Islamists extreme threat of death for all mankind] and opponents on the other chanting in support of a constitution without religious preferences and that protects minorities. Article 2 of the proposed constitution establishes Islam as the state religion. "Principles of Islamic Sharia are the principal source of legislation," it states. Article 219 spells out those principles as "general evidence, foundational rules, rules of jurisprudence, and credible sources accepted in Sunni doctrines and by the larger community." Article 44 outlaws blasphemy. Now that the national vote is nigh, ordinary Christians told World Watch Monitor through an interpreter that their way forward likely will be a longer, harder grind under a system of laws tilted against anyone who is not Muslim.
  • Nessuno Unius REI
    Nessuno Unius REI ha pubblicato un commento 
    16 minuti fa
    [Islamists extreme threat of death for all mankind] "The result will be fraud and the Brotherhood will win," said Meshel Gerges, 30, a Catholic electrical engineer. "Nothing will happen for us as Christians after the ratification of the constitution in the short term. But I think after two years they will get rid of their enemies," Gerges said. "The church will face persecution and they will not allow us to build churches." Meriam Hana Wadeaa, a 32-year-old industrial manager and a Coptic Christian, said "we will see bad days" under the constitution. "Life will be pitched," she said. "Everyone is scared and don't know what they do (except) pray to God to save us from this nightmare quickly."
  • Nessuno Unius REI
    Nessuno Unius REI ha pubblicato un commento 
    16 minuti fa
    saudi arabia imperialism for satanAllah [Islamists extreme threat of death for all mankind] "The constitution is not appropriate for us as Christians because the Muslim Brotherhood and the Salafis are the majority who wrote the constitution," said Sameha Ibrahem, a 45-year-old cleaning worker and Coptic Christian. "My feelings toward it are a very intense fear for my children and the country." The mutation of Egypt's revolution against a dictator into a sectarian struggle troubles Mohamed El Dahshan, a Cairo-based economist and policy adviser. "Painting society as a pro-Islam vs. anti-Islam binary choice isn't a political dispute -- it's a civil one," El Dahshan blogged Monday for Foreign Policy Magazine. "Because there isn't a region, a street, a family where people don't disagree about politics; if this kitchen table conversation is transformed into one about faith, then we're lost.
  • Nessuno Unius REI
    Nessuno Unius REI ha pubblicato un commento 
    16 minuti fa
    saudi arabia imperialism for satanAllah [Islamists extreme threat of death for all mankind] And the damage will reach all the way to the deepest threads of the society that we love to compare -- mostly thanks to a Christian minority that throws in some diversity -- to a complex, tightly woven tapestry." Giving voice to El Dahshan's fear, several Christians who spoke with World Watch Monitor said talk of leaving Egypt for good is common in their church congregations. Among his young church peers, 25-year-old teacher Michel Rauof said there are worries the approval of the constitution will make a bad economic situation worse, and that the unemployed will simply be forgotten. "Many think of emigration, but there is no way to emigrate," he said through an interpreter.
  • Nessuno Unius REI
    Nessuno Unius REI ha pubblicato un commento 
    17 minuti fa
    [Islamists extreme threat of death for all mankind] Though they are likely to come out on the short end of Saturday's constitutional referendum, Egypt's 10 million Christians will not be left completely empty-handed. "If this constitution were allowed, there are natural and legitimate channels to make the objection of people and organizations," Dr. Reverend Safwat Al-Bayaadi, head of the Anglican Communion in Egypt, told World Watch Monitor through an interpreter. "And we will do so, but the church does not call for disobedience. We'll look for ways and legitimate channels for objection and request for reconsideration. However, we reject disobedience." A Christian history professor in Cairo, speaking anonymously to protect his position, said believers will have little option but to confront injustices directly, and loudly.
  • Nessuno Unius REI
    Nessuno Unius REI ha pubblicato un commento 
    17 minuti fa
    saudi rabia imperialism for satanAllah [Islamists extreme threat of death for all mankind] "The oldest and best way is continuing our resistance and exposing it to the whole world," he said. "Go publicly to the international society, while resisting on the inside." "We are preparing ourselves for a long, long struggle and battle with Islam," the professor said. "What is happening with Islamists in the streets is one part of that. We win some of these small battles. We have some of the rights we fought for." Even if Christians have run out of time to gather the votes needed to reject the proposed constitution Saturday, the professor said they continue to win converts to the cause of religious freedom for Egypt.